We should create such a thread and it should be mandatory for each participant in the thread to make a tier-list of FS games made over the past 15 years and this tier-list should be visible on every post. This will ensure endless discussion and RPG Codex will never die even if developers all over the world will stop making RPGs inb4 they stopped years ago
you are served.
(i also included Sekiro):
-Dark souls PPTD ( with fps fix, not remastered with messed up lighthing)
Best gameplay, best atmosphere, best level design
-Dark Souls remaster ( see above)
-Sekiro .
-Elden (bo)Ring
-Dark souls 2 shit gameplay and movement
-Dark Souls 3 reused assets and concepts everyehere
First three are good games , last three have highs and lows